Diving into the Abyss: The Mysteries of Eagle’s Nest Sinkhole!

Diving into the Abyss: The Mysteries of Eagle’s Nest Sinkhole!
Incident LocationDiver Full Names (Deceased)
Eagle’s Nest sinkhole, West Central FloridaJudy Bedard
Darren Spivey and Dylan Sanchez

Have you ever heard of Eagle’s Nest sinkhole, often referred to as the Mount Everest of cave diving? It’s a place where underwater cave exploration reaches New Heights, known for its stunning scenery, extreme depths, and isolated setting. But there’s a catch. Beneath its picturesque exterior, a concealed peril awaits, as numerous divers have ventured in, but how many have made it out?

Location and Description

Eagle’s Nest sinkhole is found in West Central Florida inside the Chassahowitzka Wildlife Management Area. On the surface, it may not look inviting, with greenish murky water, alligators, and annoying mosquitoes and ticks. But beneath this unimpressive exterior is a fascinating yet risky world, earning it the nickname of “dangerous beauty.” The water in this sinkhole doesn’t offer the crystal clear views you might find in other springs nearby like Bufe Springs and Weeki Wachee.

Underwater Beauty and Risks

Despite these surface challenges, a group of experienced divers bravely explores the underwater caves, considering Eagle’s Nest a hidden paradise and a top-notch cave system. Underwater visibility in Eagle’s Nest sinkhole can vary depending on factors like the Florida aquifer’s condition and recent rainfall. Sometimes natural organic debris darkens the water, but on lucky days, it becomes as clear as gin. Diving here is like stepping into another world, captivating, amazing, and full of adventure.

Eagle’s Nest sinkhole is strictly for qualified and experienced divers due to its treacherous nature. Navigating the cave system can be challenging and disorienting, even for professionals. Therefore, it’s advisable for divers to seek guidance from experienced individuals who have explored the cave before to understand its unique challenges.

Eagle's Nest map

Diving in Eagle’s Nest

Inside the Eagle’s Nest cave systems, divers must negotiate tight, narrow passages, some as short as 70 ft (21 M). The caves feature grand chambers with names like the ballroom, super room, and the pit. The ballroom leads to smaller dark passages that can extend up to 300 ft (91 M) deep in certain areas. The combination of extreme depths, total darkness, and intricate cave networks classifies it as an exceptionally advanced dive site.

Unfortunately, at least 13 divers lost their lives there since 1981, leading to a closure of the site to divers from 1999 to 2003, marked by a prominent warning sign.

A Fateful Dive

On September 11th, 2005, Judy Bedard, a 48-year-old certified cave diver and registered nurse, embarked on a dive in Eagle Nest sinkhole with her partner, Rudy Banks. Their adventure took them into the mesmerizing but hazardous underwater cave system, descending 300 ft (91 M) below the Earth’s surface. The complex network of passages extended over a mile, presenting formidable challenges.

In one stretch of the cavern known as “the pit,” the tunnel reaches depths of 300 ft (91 M). It’s a sight of both wonder and risk. Judy and Rudy began their dive with a gradual descent into the cave, and everything was proceeding smoothly. However, at a depth of 130 ft (40 m), technical issues started to plague Judy’s equipment.

Technical Issues and Critical Decision

To address the situation, Judy transitioned to her triix tank, but the gas mixture wasn’t correctly balanced for this depth. Recognizing the problem, Judy switched back to her Nitrox tank, and both divers initiated their ascent towards the surface. In cave diving, ascent should be gradual to prevent decompression sickness, commonly known as “the bends.” However, time was not on their side for a slow decompression due to the gas mixture error.

As they reached a depth of 100 ft (30 m), Judy lost consciousness. Her breathing ceased at approximately 60 ft (18 M) from the surface. Faced with a dire situation, Rudy had a difficult decision to make. Judy’s life hung in the balance with still 60 ft (18 M) of water above them.

A rapid ascent risked exacerbating Judy’s condition due to her already oxygen-depleted state. Rudy opted for a swift ascent, understanding that it offered a slim chance of recovering from decompression sickness compared to certain death within the cave.

Race Against Time

He swiftly brought Judy to the surface, where he desperately needed assistance to revive her. Greg Stanton, a former diving safety officer at Florida State University, and his friend James Gary, a member of the University of South Florida’s diving control board, came to Rudy’s aid. After completing their dives, Greg lamented that it was the ascent that initiated a series of challenges for Judy, including arterial gas embolisms.

Upon reaching the surface, Judy had no pulse, and distressingly, her eyes were open with blood and foam emanating from her mouth. James enlisted the help of Dan Pent, a Spring Hill resident at Eagle’s Nest for photography, and they dialed 911 using Pen’s phone.

Rudy and Pen performed CPR, a vital life-saving technique given Judy’s condition. After 15-20 minutes of CPR, Judy’s heart started beating again, and her breathing was restored. However, she remained unconscious and in dire need of medical attention.

Unfortunately, help was not readily accessible at Eagle’s Nest sinkhole due to its remote location and challenging unpaved entrance. In Judy’s case, insufficient supplies and transportation hurdles hindered the medical response. She had to be transported using a sport utility vehicle backboard, without an IV drip. Ambulance and helicopter services were on standby in the nearby forest to expedite her journey to the hospital.

Factors Contributing to the Incident

Fish and wildlife investigator Steven Farmer made three key statements regarding the factors that led to Judy’s injuries at the cave site, echoing the sentiments of Greg and James. These included poorly mixed gases in her trimix tanks, inadequate analysis of gas proportions, and the closure of the isolation valve connecting the two tanks, which Judy failed to check before the dive.

Some experts contended that Judy bore responsibility for her equipment. It is the responsibility of all divers to meticulously check their breathing gases before commencing a dive. A simple check of the isolation valve might have revealed the uneven tank pressures and potentially prevented further complications, prompting the cancellation of the dive.

Recovery and Rehabilitation

Rudy endured a period of profound unhappiness due to Judy’s deteriorating health. Judy’s condition warranted her transfer to Shands, where her status was categorized as critical. Early on, hope for her recovery was dim, with doctors expressing amazement at her survival during the first 24 hours post-dive.

Kidney failure and multiple heart attacks followed her treatment in the hyperbaric chamber, where the goal was to expedite the removal of gas bubbles caused by air embolisms. Judy’s vibrant and cheerful personality, known to friends and fellow divers, made her ordeal even more difficult to accept. Her vibrant spirit seemed at odds with the cruel twist of fate she had endured.

Transported to Tampa General Hospital, Judy embarked on a rigorous rehabilitation journey. Her full consciousness didn’t return until 2 months after the incident in November. Recalling the moment, she said, “I remember waking up unable to move with atrophied legs and a tracheostomy tube. I thought, ‘Oh my God.'”

Throughout her hospitalization, Judy faced cardiac arrest, respiratory failure, multiple organ complications, cognitive decline, and post-traumatic amnesia.

The Recovery and Rehabilitation of Judy Bedard

After Judy Bedard’s dive incident, she faced neurological and physical impairments, potentially experiencing paralysis, initially requiring assistance with basic mobility. Months of intensive therapy followed, leading to remarkable progress. Her recovery was nothing short of miraculous, as described by one of her doctors and her former brain injury team. In January 2006, Judy spent six more months in outpatient therapy, regaining her strength, flexibility, and coordination.

The following summer, she achieved her dream of an open water dive with Rudy in the Gulf of Mexico. In June 2007, Judy returned to work at Tampa General Hospital, opting for the medical records division to accommodate her passion for diving while reducing overtime hours.

Darren and Dylan’s Dive at Eagle’s Nest

In 2014, Darren Spivey and his son, Dylan Sanchez, set out on a dive to Eagle’s Nest with their new dive equipment. Darren, a lifelong diving enthusiast, often brought friends along for weekend swims. However, he lacked specialized cave diving credentials, which became pertinent for deeper exploration.

Six months prior, Darren met Robert Brooks, a seasoned cave diver who became a potential mentor. Brooks insisted on cave certification before any joint expeditions, and he encouraged Darren to pursue certification. Dylan, a Hernando High School freshman, shared his father’s enthusiasm and diligently studied dive manuals, striving for expertise. Eagle’s Nest was no stranger to them, having dived there several times, well aware of its inherent risks.

The Fatal Dive

Darren and Dylan began their dive at Eagle’s Nest, initially planning to stay in the ballroom, a cavern within Eagle Nest reaching depths of around 200 ft (61 m), avoiding the perilous tunnels. However, they ventured beyond the ballroom entrance, into a lengthy narrow tunnel beneath the surface. They continued their descent into the cavern, aware of their dwindling oxygen supply, facing a prolonged decompression process due to their extreme depth.

Such deep dives require a specialized gas mixture with helium to reduce narcotic effects. Robert Brooks believed they lacked sufficient air for this process, and they used plain compressed air, lacking this critical mixture.

The Desperate Search

Holly, Darren’s fiance, became worried when hours passed without contact, and she drove to the site herself. After learning of the missing divers, the police were contacted. Robert Brooks enlisted two certified cave divers to aid in the search. The police deployed trained recovery divers to locate the missing pair.

At a depth of 67 ft (20 m), one of the divers discovered Dylan’s body floating against the ballroom ceiling. Darren’s body was found at a depth of 127 ft (39 m) on a large mound on the ballroom floor. Their dive computers and air gauges showed that they had both descended to 200 ft (61 m) and had run out of air.

Investigation and Conclusion

According to authorities, the drownings appear to result from a diver who attempted to go beyond his training and experience. An investigation into what went wrong was underway. Robert Brooks, who assisted in the recovery, explained that he had warned Darren that they might get into trouble. Despite setting up their equipment meticulously, the tragic incident occurred.

The treacherous underwater cave system at Eagle’s Nest sinkhole has claimed the lives of multiple divers.

Darren and Dylan’s Fatal Dive

Darren and Dylan’s tragic deaths serve as a stark reminder of the perils in this infamous underwater cave system.

Lack of Experience and Proper Gear

Lack of experience and proper gear in a place like Eagle’s Nest proved fatal. They descended to 230 ft (70 m) with inadequate preparation, lacking the right gas mixture and essential training and equipment. Their deaths were investigated, assuming they followed the guideline into one of the two caves where they likely experienced nitrogen narcosis, a drowsy sensation induced by high-pressure air below 100 ft, causing disorientation and poor judgment.

Tragic Sequence of Events

They likely ran out of oxygen upon returning to the ballroom. Dylan likely ran out of air first, and Darren tried to share his regulator before passing out. Darren’s tank depleted rapidly, and he sank, while Dylan made a desperate ascent but lost the guideline and couldn’t find the exit.

Tragically, Eagle’s Nest has claimed the lives of multiple divers, serving as a stark reminder of the perils involved in cave diving, especially in challenging underwater cave systems. Divers are urged to come well-prepared, prioritize safety, and be aware of the inherent risks when exploring such environments.

Before your next dive, consider insurance – it’s like having a dive buddy for unexpected challenges. Dive safe, dive covered. Explore options here


How deep is Eagle’s Nest sinkhole?

Eagle’s Nest sinkhole can reach depths of up to 315 feet (91 meters), making it a challenging and deep cave diving location.

What is the water temperature in the cave?

The water temperature inside Eagle’s Nest sinkhole remains relatively constant at around 72°F (22°C) throughout the year.

Is Eagle’s Nest suitable for novice divers?

No, Eagle’s Nest is strictly for qualified and experienced divers due to its treacherous nature and complex cave systems. It’s not recommended for novice divers.

Patrick Broin
Patrik, a seasoned cave diver, shares his first-hand experiences and expert insights on the treacherous world of cave diving accidents.
All diving accidents