Lost in the Depths: The Cave Diving Tragedy of Cova de Sa Piqueta

Incident LocationDiver Names
Cova De sa Piqueta, SpainJustin, Lionel, and Sebastian

A group of five divers entered the Cova de Sa Piqueta for exploration. On their way back, they kicked up silt, and three divers took the wrong turn, leading them in the wrong direction. With poor visibility and no sense of direction, they awaited rescue before their air ran out.

Exploration and Discovery

In 2012, an almost invisible surface current was detected during exploration within the unexplored pool located on the western side of Cova Desa paqueta. Motivated by this discovery, a group of cave divers decided to embark on a return expedition to further delve into the depths of the cave.

Their relentless efforts persisted for over 55 days, leading to the remarkable discovery of numerous previously unknown chambers spanning a remarkable length of 18,307 feet. As a result, the Cova de Sa Piqueta has now extended to an impressive length of 28,215 feet, with 20,498 feet submerged beneath the water. The cave comprises a total of six interconnected systems, each with its distinct sector.

Meeting of Divers

During their time in college, Andrew, Philip, Justin, Lionel, and Sebastian crossed paths while on a memorable field trip to Cenote Azul, where they engaged in an open-air swimming experience. Bonding over their shared fascination with the underwater realm, they discovered that Andrew and Philip had official certifications as cave divers. This realization sparked a deep curiosity within the remaining members of the group, leading them to consider pursuing their certifications in Cave Diving.

Daring Decision

Although the group members were still in the process of completing their certification requirements, their eagerness and overwhelming fascination with the underwater world pushed them towards a daring decision. They convinced Andrew and Philip to join forces and explore the depths of Cova de Sa Piqueta as a unified team. Initially, the certified divers had reservations and hesitations regarding this arrangement; however, after persistent and persuasive appeals from their friends, Andrew and Philip eventually reconsidered, agreeing to embark on the adventure together.

The Dive Begins

The long-awaited day for the dive had finally arrived. As the men stepped into the cave, they were embraced by the damp air, which enveloped them in its coolness. Gradually, they went deeper into the cave’s darkness. Before embarking on this dive, they meticulously ensured that their air supply was sufficient for the entire expedition, including exploration, operation, and return, with an additional hour in reserve for unforeseen emergencies. With the regulator securely held in their mouths, they dipped their heads beneath the water’s surface, ready for their first-ever group dive.

Guided by Experience

Guiding the group with their expertise and experience, Andrew and Philip assumed the lead positions because they were the professional cave divers. Following closely behind were Justin, Lionel, and Sebastian, eager to immerse themselves in this thrilling adventure. The divers skillfully dived through the intricate network of narrow and winding tunnels to navigate the underwater maze.

They relied on a simple yet time-tested tool: thin, durable nylon guidelines adorned with labeled markers. These markers served as vital signposts, differentiating the various paths and preventing potential wrong turns, which would otherwise be nearly indistinguishable without the aid of the guidelines.

Loss of Visibility

The exploration of the cave proceeded smoothly without encountering any major obstacles. As the divers began their journey back, they retraced their path, following the familiar route they had taken earlier. However, they realized that their movements had disturbed the silty sediments settled on the cave floor, leading to a significant reduction in visibility.

This sudden loss of clarity caused a wave of panic to surge through their minds, especially the inexperienced divers. Nevertheless, Andrew and Philip, drawing upon their experience and expertise in navigating such challenging situations, moved ahead, thinking the rest of the group was trailing closely behind.

Wrong Turn and Darkness

Unfortunately, unbeknownst to them, Justin, Lionel, and Sebastian became separated from Andrew and Philip at a Y junction. They mistakenly dove towards another tunnel, believing that their chosen path was correct due to its ascending pathway.

Adding to their distress, their diving lights unexpectedly went off, plunging them into darkness. The group unknowingly continued swimming into the wrong tunnel, diverting themselves further away from the actual exit.

Desperate Wait for Rescue

Meanwhile, Andrew and Philip successfully made their way out of the cave, only to come with a shocking realization that they were not accompanied by the other three members of their group. Their extended exploration had caused them to spend an excessive amount of time and depth, requiring a two-hour decompression period before they could embark on the search for their friends.

After progressing for a considerable distance, Justin, Lionel, and Sebastian gradually became aware of their situation. The passage they had been following led them to yet another dead end within the vast expanse of the cave. To their surprise, their depth gauge indicated a mere eight feet below the water’s surface. Panic washed over them, leading to their desperate search for the correct path.

Unfortunately, their movements only succeeded in stirring up more silt, further diminishing the already compromised visibility. Failing to locate the correct route, they found themselves in a life-threatening situation with no immediate means of escape. They had no choice but to wait for rescue in the darkness that enveloped them. Time seemed to stretch infinitely as they endured three long hours, painfully aware that the dwindling supply of their gas cylinders was their lifeline.

They knew that once their final gas reserves were depleted, their chances of survival would be gone. Despite the uncertainty, they desperately hoped for and anticipated the arrival of timely assistance that could potentially save their lives.

Rescue and Recovery

After completing their mandatory decompression stop, Andrew and Phillip swiftly prepared themselves once again to dive back into the depths and search for their missing friends. Given that their primary diving light was dead, they were fortunate to have spare lights readily available. Upon reaching the Y junction, they realized that the alternate branch of the Y showed signs of silt disturbance, suggesting recent movement along this alternate route.

Despite the darkness in the path, they directed their torches toward the passage, illuminating their way forward as they pressed on, straining their eyes to discern any signs of life. A heartbreaking sight emerged before them—three motionless bodies floated in the water, unmistakably recognizable as those of their dear friends.

A profound sense of despair settled upon Andrew and Philip, their hearts sinking with the weight of sorrow and grief. Their fallen friends had drowned while unable to find their way to safety. The reserves within their primary tanks, their decompression tanks, and even their 100 percent O2 tank designated for the final stage of decompression had been used up. Faced with the task of retrieving their fallen friends and the reality of the tunnel being silted out once again, Andrew and Philip realized that they were unable to single-handedly bring the bodies to safety.

With heavy hearts, they made the difficult decision to exit the cave and seek external assistance, reaching out to the appropriate authorities. The authorities promptly organized a recovery operation scheduled to take place the following day. Aware of the risks and challenges involved, they assembled a team of four experienced divers. Despite Andrew and Philip’s strong desire to participate in the recovery operation and honor their friends, they were gently advised to remain on the sidelines.

The following day arrived, and the recovery team, having enhanced visibility due to improved conditions within the cave, went forth. The bodies of the divers were brought out of the cave successfully. Before venturing into the depths of a cave, it is of the utmost importance to possess the appropriate training and experience. Diving in caves should never be taken lightly, and we must consistently ask ourselves a vital question: “Am I adequately trained and experienced to undertake this dive safely?”

Lessons and Conclusion

Another aspect to be mindful of during cave diving is the careful management of our fins. While caves often offer good visibility due to reduced wind and currents, it is crucial to exercise caution.

The cave bottoms are frequently covered in fine silt, and the walls may have algae or other organic growth. Engaging in finning movements can inadvertently disturb the sediments, leading to a sudden flurry of particles that drastically diminishes visibility in a matter of seconds. In any diving situation, it is vital to maintain composure and avoid giving in to panic.

Panic has a detrimental effect on our ability to handle challenging circumstances, as it disrupts our focus and affects our rational thinking. Panic-induced responses include rapid and deep breathing, which can lead to further complications. Uncontrolled movements may also arise, aggravating the situation. Therefore, it is crucial to cultivate a calm mindset, prioritizing rational decision-making and exercising self-control even in the face of adversity.

In conclusion, cave diving is an exhilarating yet risky adventure. It demands specialized training, experience, and preparation. It is essential to approach cave diving with utmost caution and respect for the underwater environment. Adhering to proper safety protocols and maintaining composure in challenging situations can make all the difference between a successful dive and a tragic incident. Cave divers must be well-equipped, both in terms of skills and mindset, to navigate through the darkness and find their way back to safety.

Before your next dive, consider insurance – it’s like having a dive buddy for unexpected challenges. Dive safe, dive covered. Explore options here


Where did the incident occur?

Incident Location: Cova Desa Paquetta, Spain.

Who were the divers involved in the incident?

Diver Names: Justin, Lionel, and Sebastian.

What led to the divers getting separated?

The divers kicked up silt, leading to poor visibility, and three divers took the wrong turn.

How long did the group explore the cave?

The group explored the cave for over 55 days.

Were all the divers rescued?

Unfortunately, three divers lost their lives, while two were successfully rescued.

Patrick Broin
Patrik, a seasoned cave diver, shares his first-hand experiences and expert insights on the treacherous world of cave diving accidents.
All diving accidents