Tragic Incident at Otter Springs: The Loss of Kenneth Ives in a Cave Diving Accident

Incident LocationDiver Full Name
USA, Florida, Otter SpringsKenneth Ives

Introduction to Otter Springs

In 1990, four men went for a dive into the cave at Otter Springs. They had just received their certification for open water diving. They refused the advice of their diving instructor not to go into the cave, and a horrible tragedy followed. Please consider subscribing to our channel for more exciting cave diving stories! Otter Springs is a second-magnitude spring located west of Trenton along the Suwannee River, Florida.

About 10 million gallons of pure sparkling water flow from Otter Springs daily. The temperature is about 23 °C (73 °F). The large, clear pool and stream at Otter Springs flow directly into the Suwannee River. The spring is encompassed by ancient oaks and towering cypress. There are several outdoor activities you can engage yourself with at Otter Springs Park and Campground, which is seated upon 636 acres (257 hectares) of land.

These include hiking, picnicking, fishing, bird watching, and many others. The poolside table and the swim laps that are at the enclosed pavilion give a comforting experience when you are relaxing indoors or outdoors. Search no further if you want a perfect place to camp and explore the natural coast of Florida.

The Ill-Fated Dive

Otter Springs is one out of a million. The main spring and cabin areas trail naturally to Little Otter Springs, a spring that’s along the Suwannee River. It was just after taking a lunch break at a campground in Gainesville, Florida, on a beautiful afternoon on May 19, 1990. Jackie Galvin and her students, Ron and Allen Welch, who were brothers, Chris Gallup, and Kenneth Ives, left for a picnic at a campground in Gainesville, Florida.

The five all enjoyed their lunch at the campground. They had suggested a dive to the spring that was just right at the center of the campground. Jackie, their diving instructor, was an experienced diver. Ron also was an experienced diver as he had dived about 52 times. Allen, Chris, and Kenneth, on the other hand, were just beginning their diving adventures, having completed less than seven dives and only recently received diving certification.

It was pleasurable for them all to have an opportunity to dive here at Otter Springs. But their certifications were only for open-water diving and not cave diving. Jackie, their instructor, tried to discourage them from proceeding with the dive. Why on Earth would anyone try cave diving with open-water training and without all the necessary equipment and experience? Kenneth was very anxious about the dive and was not going to allow anyone or anything to discourage him from experiencing life underwater that afternoon.

All his friends persuaded him not to go, but he just wouldn’t listen. As a result, they all left and began diving into the 40 ft (12 m) cave without the permission of their instructor. Others had followed in case Kenneth needed help down there. They didn’t have a spare set of tanks, no rescue line, just a willing heart, and a little diving equipment.

Trapped in the Cave

Jackie signaled to them to stop and return to the surface, but none of them would return. She became mad at their disobedience, but there was nothing she could do. The four of them had already entered the water. Ron, Allen, Chris, and Kenneth continued diving into the murky waters of Otter Springs. Before long, they lost their way into the caves due to impaired visibility caused by silt in the water.

That was one incident that was expected from such a dive adventure. This was the same thing Jackie wanted to avoid, but they wouldn’t listen. Coupled with being lost within the silted-up cave, they were running out of air too; their oxygen gauge was now reading zero. Allen and Chris had lost contact with Kenneth in the cave.

They also began to find their way but to no avail. They both began buddy breathing. When they discovered that they were running out of air, they decided to move to the top of the cave. They were able to get some air here, and they stayed in this indentation in the ceiling. Ron, on the other hand, was lost in the mud.

He was more experienced than the other three. That was an advantage to him, so he was able to navigate through the mud. He activated his purge valve, which is diving equipment that can be used to clear the water out of the breathing tube. Then Ron found his way to the surface. On getting to the surface, he met Jackie, their instructor, who was both furious and in a panic at what might befall them within the cave.

They were lost and were yet to find their way back to the surface. Ron, who had thought he was the last to come out, asked the instructor, but to his greatest surprise, he was told he was the first to make it out. Ron knew something would have gone wrong. Ron knew what difficulties he had to pass through to get out of the cave, though he had some experience.

Rescue Arrives

What would those inexperienced divers do to manage themselves to get to the surface? Only a rescue could help them. Jackie wanted to get into the water, but that would be a wrong and dangerous decision to take. She had an empty air cylinder; there was no rescue line, and her suit didn’t have helmet lights.

With all these limitations, a successful rescue operation could not be carried out from her end. Fortunately for them, there was at the picnic ground a well-experienced cave diver, an expert, Woody Jasper. Woody Jasper, vice president of operations for Continental Water in Gainesville, had just been at the park for a company picnic.

Bob Weeks, an experienced cave diver, was also at the picnic. When he saw them panicking at the surface, he moved closer and discovered that they had three inexperienced divers down there in the water. He asked Ron and Jackie on the surface if those in the water had full diving gear or were certified cave divers.

But the answers he got were negative. He knew that another tragedy was right at the door if nothing was done immediately. He ran to the picnic ground to fetch Woody Jasper. Bob quickly explained the situation at the cave site to him, that some divers were trapped in there and needed help right away. He told others at the picnic to call 911 as he sped to his truck, got his suit, and made his way quickly to the water.

Each of the tanks Ron, Allen, Chris, and Kenneth had initially carried into the cave could contain 40 gallons of compressed air that could last them for one hour. But whenever a diver is anxious, he will hyperventilate. Hyperventilation simply means rapid or deep breathing, which occurs as a result of anxiety or panic.

This will certainly make him consume more air than normal. Jasper knew they had to do something quickly. It had been one hour since they had been running up and down looking for help. The bubbles they had been seeing within the cave had stopped. This was a pointer to them that those guys had drowned. Jackie knew this.

Successful Rescue Operation

Ten years before this incident, Jasper had mapped this cave on one of his explorations. He knew what was inside: a safety tunnel and an air pocket near it. He entered the water and dived into the tunnel. He discovered that they all had their tanks and masks on the floor. When he found the 25-year-old Allen on the ceiling, he quickly revived him and pulled him out.

Allen was brought back to the surface; his two lungs had collapsed. Cathy and those on the surface began to perform CPR on him. They flushed out the water from his system, and he began to breathe. Jasper had returned to the water in search of the remaining two divers. He found Chris, close to the place he had found Allen.

He used his purge valve to revive him too. Chris was still very much conscious. Jasper held his hands, and they came out together to the surface. They started conducting CPR for him at the surface too. Jasper returned to the cave in search of the last man, Kenneth. He continued searching for another hour before he found him at the bottom, about 80 ft (24 m) away from the place he found his friends.

When Jasper brought him to the surface, all the efforts of the CPR and EMS teams proved abortive. Kenneth was declared dead. Allen was taken to a hyperbaric chamber at a hospital in Miami, where his lungs were reinflated. The thought of him having permanent brain damage terrified them at the hospital. Allen survived the trauma but made a promise never to return for a cave dive again in his life.

Chris and Ron, on the other hand, continued with cave diving but would never attempt any dives without proper training. Jasper acknowledged that if they had come to him for proper cave dive training, they would have avoided such a terrible experience. Kenneth Ives, 25 years old, was from Pinellas Park, Florida.

He was formerly an altar boy and also an assistant manager at the Publix supermarket in Florida. Such a sad end for a promising young man and his dreams.

Before your next dive, consider insurance – it’s like having a dive buddy for unexpected challenges. Dive safe, dive covered. Explore options here


What activities can I do at Otter Springs Park and Campground?

At Otter Springs Park and Campground, you can engage in activities such as hiking, picnicking, fishing, bird watching, and more.

Where is Otter Springs located?

Otter Springs is located west of Trenton along the Suwannee River in Florida.

What happened during the ill-fated dive at Otter Springs?

During the ill-fated dive, four men who had recently received their open water diving certification went cave diving without proper training and equipment. They got lost in the cave and ran out of air, resulting in a tragedy.

How were the trapped divers rescued?

Experienced cave diver Woody Jasper, who was at the park during a company picnic, was called upon for help. He dove into the cave and successfully rescued two of the trapped divers by reviving them using his diving equipment. Unfortunately, one of the divers did not survive.

What happened to the survivors after the incident?

One survivor experienced collapsed lungs but was revived and survived. He vowed never to go cave diving again without proper training. The other survivors continued with cave diving but recognized the importance of proper training before attempting any dives.

Patrick Broin
Patrik, a seasoned cave diver, shares his first-hand experiences and expert insights on the treacherous world of cave diving accidents.
All diving accidents